Remembrance Sunday
We recall on this day all those who have given their lives in warfare and conflict. Warfare, violence and bloodshed remain with us even though we pray earnestly for the peace of the world: have our prayers not been heard? One has to admit that this is not an easy Sunday to deal with each year. For I speak to you as one who has not experienced war at first hand – only through the sanitized barrier of the television screen. We are asked to remember today – but that is hard if you have never experienced something. Two years ago we saw the 100th anniversary of World War One. Very, very few are now alive who can recall that atrocious war with such massive and seemingly pointless loss of young lives. That conflict changed the outlook of this nation: but for all of us it is a distant memory of a past era.
It is poignant then, that in recent years instead of the two minutes silence falling out of use, instead it has taken on a greater significance – with a renewed call to fall silent at the 11th hour on the 11th day of the 11th month. Why should this be? The Christian life we seek to live throws up a variety of opposites that we need to hold in tension in order to understand our faith – and that reflects itself in our national life too. As the generations pass, there is a real risk that we shall lose a clear and direct understanding of the valiant sacrifices that were made – there is a danger of simply forgetting. Our own day and age is not immune to war and violence – we see it depicted daily as it is brought into our homes through the TV screen: its horrors still shock us – so it is hard to imagine what it does to the minds of those who lived through it. Even so, the danger remains that we shall forget the sacrifice that allows us to live in relative freedom and with a tolerable level of peace. The dichotomy is daring to forget while fearing to remember. The writer E.M. Forster said “Unless we remember we cannot understand.” (Repeat).
Some have argued that the time has come to do away with Remembrancetide – possibly as it is over 100 years since the outbreak of WW1 falls. The war memorials and the war graves are remembrance enough now that those who survived that war have now died anyway. Why relive the memory? Best to let it pass into history. Can we ever hope to find world peace while we dwell on past conflicts and hatreds?
But the answer lies, surely, in a proper balance between remembering and forgetting? We need to hold the two in a tension, to live with the paradox that it would be wrong simply to consign the war dead to the pages of history. As a nation, as a community, we are shaped by our history. There are lessons still to be learned through what passed before we were even born. Our Christian faith speaks of this tension – Christ died that we may have life. Only in sacrificing ourselves to what we truly believe in do we find answers to life’s questions – e.g. we receive by giving away.
Words we hear at every Mass: “do this in memory of me” Jesus says. We recall at every Mass the sacrifice made by Christ – who offered himself once and for all for us. He died to make us free: free from sin and eternal death. Christ’s sacrifice was made, we need to remember, for the forgiveness of sins – Jesus Christ took upon himself the sins of the whole world and offered himself to the father of all mercies. Through Christ, God has forgotten our sins, Christ destroyed the memory of them on our behalf. Through our Baptism into sharing the life of Christ, the slate has been wiped clean and we have the opportunity to gain eternal life.
Some will say that forgiveness and forgetting are distinct and different: they are, in one sense. But when one hears someone saying “I’ll forgive him but I won’t forget what he did to me”, it is only natural to question just how genuine the forgiveness really is when we still harbour a grudge against that person. Such supposed forgiveness bears little resemblance to what Christ did for us on the Cross – he gave up his very life to win for us eternal life.
The wrong sort of long memory can work against its own purposes. We can all think of instances where the festering of ancient grievances is like a poison which slowly destroys any chance of the opportunity for new beginnings. Holding on to past injuries, whether personal, family, neighbourly or national runs directly counter to what we say every time we recite the Lord’s Prayer. We say the words so easily – but do we really pray them – forgive us our sins as we forgive those who sin against us. There is no harbouring of old grievances there. We are forgiven in the same measure that we truly forgive others.
The fear is, on Remembrance Sunday, that we might forget – and by so doing, diminish the heroic sacrifice made by thousands – not just in WW1, but in all the conflicts that has broken out since then for which people gave the ultimate sacrifice of their lives in the cause of peace and freedom. But the remembering we do is no so that we can continue to harbour resentment or anger. It is a fine line to draw. But it is the remembrance of Christ’s sacrifice that is pivotal to our understanding of the place of remembrance: fort it is a fundamental part of our Christian way of living. For we recall – relive, bring into the present His one sacrifice each time we offer the elements of bread and wine on the altar. We don’t add to Christ’s sacrifice of himself: for that was entire, whole and complete – a perfect offering to His Father. But we share in his sacrifice as we share the bread and wine now made his body and his blood. It is for us a living sacrifice for it makes us one with Him. Thus it is healthy and life-giving to remember this sacrifice. But it is equally healthy to set aside and forget past animosity. Sins are truly forgiven when we confess them – they are gone, past and over. So on this Remembrance Sunday, it is right to remember the fallen. We give thanks for the peace they won for us and for the cause of freedom they fought for, however misguided their motives may have been for going to war in the first place. The cause of peace still needs our prayers because humankind has not learned the lessons of past conflicts and still tyrants need to be overthrown. And there is still the call to repentance that we must all heed in order to be made aware of God’s abiding and forgiving love of the sinner who repents. E.M. Forster’s words bear some reflection: “Unless we remember we cannot understand”.
Fr. Timothy Bugby
13th November 2016