Week 18. Year C. Cromer and Sheringham. 30th/31st July 2016

It is my supposition, or observation, that the world is divided into those who feel they always get it right and those who feel that whatever they do, it always goes wrong. The eternal optimist and the eternal pessimist. It is a generalization, I know: but it is possible to discern it in people – what their outlook on life is: where their priorities lie. Some years ago I was persuaded to purchase a 17th century Durer print entitled “Melancholia” which it was felt summed me up – always managing to put a dampener on any special occasion – so you know which group I fall into!

You may recall that some years ago now there was a tremendous hype about the sinking of the Titanic. There was not only the film of that name with Kate Winslet and Leonardo di Caprio, but with the centenary being commemorated, increased interest in memorabilia from the sunken ship and the wreck itself. At its most extreme, a couple wished to be married underwater on the wreck itself – which caused a huge furore as many people felt that as so many people perished as a result of that tragedy, it was rather insensitive to disturb what is, in fact, a burial site. This couple simply got it wrong – their wish to “get it right” for their big day was a big mistake.

And we can take the same allegory further – that the people on the Titanic in the first class dining room who went down with the ship died because they refused to believe the facts of the matter. They were told the ship was unsinkable: so carried on with their dinner as the orchestra played on. Lifeboats were launched half-empty because passengers refused to get into them – because the ship wouldn’t sink. Likewise, the designers of the ship believed it was unsinkable, so altered the plans to allow for fewer lifeboats because it reduced the number of sun decks for the rich and famous and spoiled the sleek lines of the vessel. They simply got it wrong: misjudged the facts of the situation.

So we turn to today’s Gospel. Jesus was asked to settle an inheritance dispute. Rightly Jesus declines to intervene: but seeing into the man’s soul, he sees that it is not a squabble about money but a misplaced priority about his own worth and greed. There is a parallel with the grand passengers on the sinking liner – it couldn’t possibly sink if THEY were on it! This man asking Jesus for advice looks to wealth and riches as a form of security. They will surely save him. Jesus warns him that they will not only let him down, but also blind him from discerning the true priorities of life.

Note in the story: Jesus does not condemn this attitude as sinful or wicked, simply “wrong”. It is a trait that our society has lost sight of – these days, there always has to be someone to blame, someone to sue, if something goes wrong. Politicians would do better, as would leaders in business, if they held their hands up occasionally and simply admitted that they got it wrong rather than hiding behind a whole host of excuses – blaming everything and everyone. All it needs is the swallowing of a bit of pride and we might see them as a bit more credible and human. Owning up and being honest does leave us with a degree of integrity. No-one is perfect and we are all capable of making mistakes.

In the Gospel story, this man’s wealth blinds him to what is important in life. His materialist outlook will save him, he thinks. He “is” what he “owns”. Thus he is blinded by thinking that this life is all there is. We would say that he needs to broaden his horizons. His life centres on “I, me and mine” – rather than acknowledging, ultimately, a need for God in his life. He has become isolated, inward looking.

It is all about priorities: learning to get the balance right. There is nothing wrong in owning “things” as long as they don’t shield us from the daily business of “living”, especially living in community – in relation to other people. It raises the question of what is truly worth hanging on to – a barn bursting with grain (or a modern equivalent) or love, friendship and ultimately a vision of a life in the future beyond the purely materialistic?

  1. Paul tells us that greed is the same as idolatry. Our security lies in God alone: He is the source and sustainer of our life. Belonging to either the optimistic camp or the pessimistic camp does colour one’s outlook on life. Whichever we are, we need to look below the surface of what can so easily become a shallow existence: like those dining passengers on the sinking ship – it couldn’t possibly sink – because the ship’s builders said so. But even they could have done something towards trying to save themselves even if they were doomed to drown. There were some lifeboats available. We need to learn of our need for God in our lives: but we have to do something to help ourselves as well – and have a sense of pride in our well-being and the choices we make in life.

As Julian of Norwich famously said: “all things shall be well, all manner of things shall be well. For all will be all in all and all will be in God”. It is that godly element which ultimately matters – to know that we not only own things but that we are owned by, (we belong to) Jesus Christ. He possesses us when we profess our faith in Him and don’t believe that we have the power to save ourselves by what we accumulate over a life-time.

– Fr Tim Bugby